Workplace Success

Spying? Nay. Prospering? Yay!: Can Employee Monitoring Be Your Ally for a More Productive Workplace?

June 12, 2023
IN THIS BLOG

Imagine you're a coach leading your team to victory in a soccer game. You need to watch your players, ensuring they're playing their positions and executing the plays as planned. To do that, you watch them closely from the sidelines, give them feedback, and adjust the game plan accordingly.

But if you're too controlling, you might end up yelling at your players, nitpicking their every move, and taking away their autonomy. Your players might start to feel demotivated and disengaged, leading to a lack of team morale and poor performance.

Just like a coach who is too controlling, excessive employee monitoring can also lead to negative consequences. It can make remote workers feel like they're constantly being watched and not trusted to do their job. This can cause feelings of anxiety, stress, and resentment. However, it can be a powerful tool for companies if done right.

In this blog, we'll explore the pros and cons of employee monitoring for remote teams and why it's essential to strike the right balance. We'll discuss how mild employee monitoring can increase productivity and accountability while excessive monitoring can lead to distrust and demotivation. So, put on your coaching hat, grab your whistle, and dive into the pros and cons of employee monitoring!

TL;DR:

  • Employee monitoring can be beneficial for remote teams to ensure productivity and efficiency.
  • Excessive monitoring can lead to feelings of distrust, anxiety, and demotivation among remote workers.
  • It's essential to strike the right balance between monitoring and employee autonomy to maintain team morale.
  • Mild monitoring can increase accountability and help identify areas for improvement.
  • The disadvantages of employee monitoring include reduced job satisfaction, decreased creativity, and privacy concerns.
  • Overall, employee monitoring pros and cons must be carefully weighed and balanced to create a positive work environment for remote teams.

Advantages of Employee Monitoring

Do you remember Captain Seth Dozerman from Brooklyn Nine-Nine? Who could forget his oppressive tactics and the creepy gadget he used to keep his team members in line? 

The Dozer Pad was a monitoring device with a GPS system, a countdown clock set for 55 minutes, and even a Dozerblast option. This device allowed Dozerman to keep track of his employees' every move, making even a quick trip to the restroom feel like a daring escape from a maximum-security prison.

Read More: Positivity at Work: Top 10 Strategies to Create the Ideal Work Environment for Maximum Productivity

While the Dozer Pad's features might seem excessive and intrusive, it's important to note that not all forms of employee monitoring are created equal. When used in the right way, employee monitoring can be a useful tool for keeping remote teams productive and focused. By tracking work hours and identifying areas where employees might need additional resources or training, managers can help their teams work more efficiently and effectively.

So, let’s check out the benefits of employee monitoring and find out how a balanced system can bolster productivity in the workplace.

Keep Remote Teams Focused

Working from home can be a double-edged sword. While it’s fantastic to have the flexibility to work from the comfort of your couch (or bed, no judgment here!), it can be challenging to stay on track and focused on tasks. This is where employee monitoring comes in. By using time tracking and productivity solutions, remote teams can stay productive and efficient.

One of the main advantages of using employee monitoring is the ability to gain insights into employee behavior and work patterns. With this data, managers can identify areas for improvement and create personalized development plans to boost performance and accountability. For example, if an employee is consistently struggling with a particular task or taking longer, the data can be used to provide additional training or support.

Such a system can also help identify and address potential issues or inefficiencies in remote team workflows. For instance, if a team member consistently misses deadlines, managers can identify the root cause and work with the employee to improve their workflow. Alternatively, if a team is struggling to communicate effectively, data from the employee monitoring tool can be used to identify areas of improvement and help the team to work together more effectively. 

We also have an explainer blog on how to persuade your remote employees for time tracking. Make sure to read it.

Enhanced Security & Compliance

It’s like having a digital guardian angel looking out for your company's sensitive data. It can help ensure data security and compliance with relevant regulations in several ways.

Firstly, employee monitoring can prevent data breaches by closely monitoring who is accessing sensitive information. It's like having a security guard stationed outside the vault in a heist movie. If someone tries to access the data without authorization, the monitoring system will raise the alarm and prevent a potential breach. This is especially important in remote work environments, where employees access company data from different locations and devices.

Secondly, monitoring can help prevent unauthorized access to sensitive data by restricting access to certain employees based on their roles and responsibilities. It's like how the Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry uses a sorting hat to determine which students belong in which house. 

By assigning access levels and monitoring employee activity, you can ensure that only those who need to access specific data are able to do so.

Lastly, it can help meet compliance requirements by ensuring employees adhere to industry-specific regulations or company policies. For example, if you're in the US healthcare industry, you need to comply with the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) regulations. By monitoring employee activity, you can ensure they handle patient data according to these regulations.

Remote Team Collaboration

Employee monitoring isn't just about security and compliance; it can also help foster better collaboration among remote team members. By keeping tabs on employee activity, monitoring can help team leaders and managers identify potential bottlenecks or challenges in team workflows and address them proactively.

Imagine you're the leader of a group of Power Rangers trying to defeat a new enemy. To win, you must ensure that each team member uses their skills effectively and works together. Employee monitoring can be the Zordon to your Power Rangers, helping you keep track of everyone's progress and address any issues that arise.

By monitoring employee activity, team leaders can identify who is contributing most to the team and who may be struggling. This information can be used to allocate resources more effectively and ensure that everyone is working towards the same goals. 

Monitoring can also facilitate communication and coordination among team members. By providing insights into who is working on what and when, monitoring can help team members collaborate more efficiently. It's like how the Avengers use their individual strengths to defeat Thanos - by knowing who is capable of doing what and when, they can work together to achieve their goals.

In a remote work environment, it's easy for team members to feel disconnected. However, monitoring can help create a sense of accountability and teamwork, just like how Captain Planet unites his team to protect the environment. With monitoring, remote teams can come together and achieve great things, just like the Planeteers do.

Recommended For You: Keep Your Remote Workforce Safe from Cyber Threats!

Performance Evaluation & Recognition

Think of employee monitoring as a performance tracker for your job, similar to how a fitness tracker helps you keep track of your daily steps and workouts. By monitoring your activity levels, you can set goals and track your progress, which helps you improve your fitness and stay motivated. Similarly, employee monitoring can help employers set performance goals for their employees, track their progress, and recognize their achievements, which can boost their motivation and engagement.

Let's say you work in a sales role, and your employer uses monitoring software to track your sales performance. By analyzing data like the number of calls made, deals closed, and revenue generated, your employer can identify your strengths and weaknesses and provide feedback on improving employee performance. If you consistently exceed your targets, your employer can reward you with incentives like bonuses or promotions, which can further motivate you to perform well.

However, it's essential to use monitoring ethically and transparently to avoid violating employees' privacy rights. Therefore, employers should communicate their monitoring policies and ensure that they comply with applicable laws and regulations.

You Should Also Read: 10 Enterprise Productivity Tools to Simplify and Speed up Remote Work

Employee Development & Training

By monitoring employee performance, managers can identify areas where employees may be struggling or have skill gaps that need to be addressed. This information can then be used to provide targeted training and development opportunities to help employees improve their skills and capabilities.

Consider a hypothetical scenario in which a sales team is struggling to meet their targets. By monitoring their performance, the manager may notice that some team members are struggling to close deals while a few others are struggling with lead qualification. Armed with this knowledge, the manager can provide personalized training and development plans to address each team member's specific needs, such as additional coaching on closing techniques or training on how to qualify leads effectively.

Moreover, monitoring can be especially useful for remote team members who may not receive as much face-to-face support and feedback as their office-based colleagues. For instance, a manager who oversees a remote team of software developers can use monitoring tools to assess their productivity, quality of work, and project progress. Based on this information, the manager can identify areas where the team members may need additional training or support to improve their work. 

To put it into perspective, let's imagine a remote team that includes a developer who consistently misses project deadlines. By monitoring their performance, the manager may identify that they lack the necessary skills to complete the tasks on time. The manager can then provide additional training on project management or other relevant skills, tailored to the individual's needs. For this particular case, a time tracking app like timegram, which can automatically capture time and activity on all desktop and online applications used during work hours, can do wonders.

You’ll Also Enjoy Reading: The Four Main Types of Productivity Software and What Flint can Teach you from Cloudy with the Chance of Meatballs

Disadvantages of Employee Monitoring

We’re now moving towards the ‘cons’ part of employee monitoring pros and cons.

Let's face it, working from home can be both a blessing and a curse. Sure, you get to work in your pajamas and avoid the morning commute, but you also have to deal with distractions and temptations that can get in the way of productivity. That's why some companies have turned to employee monitoring as a way to keep tabs on their remote workers. But before you go all "Big Brother" on your team, it's important to consider the potential downsides.

The Morale-killer

One of the biggest negative effects of employee monitoring is its impact on morale and job satisfaction. Imagine feeling like your boss is always looking over your shoulder, watching your every move. Not only can this create stress and anxiety, but it can also make employees feel like they aren’t trusted or valued. Over time, this can lead to disengagement, resentment, and even burnout. Don’t let monitoring turn into surveillance.

The Privacy Issue

Another potential disadvantage of employee monitoring is the issue of privacy. Nobody wants to feel like their personal information is being shared or tracked. When employees feel invaded, it can erode trust and create discomfort. In extreme cases, it can lead to legal action.

Balancing the Pros and Cons of Employee Monitoring 

In today's ever-changing workplace, remote teams have become more commonplace. With this shift, employee monitoring has become a popular solution for many companies to ensure their remote workforce remains productive. A survey conducted by ResumeBuilder.com found that 96% of U.S. business leaders now use employee monitoring software to keep their teams on task and productive. This increase from just 10% before the pandemic outbreak shows that remote work isn’t going away any time soon.

Our analysis of employee monitoring pros and cons has shown us how this practice can be both a blessing and a curse. Monitoring is a powerful tool for boosting productivity, tightening security, and cutting costs. like any tool, it's not without its downsides. There are real concerns around privacy and trust that employers need to address. After all, no one wants to feel like they're being spied on or that their employer doesn't trust them.

That said, it's clear that remote teams need some form of system to keep everyone on track and ensure that work is getting done. It's all about finding the right balance. By using employee monitoring software judiciously and with care, employers can enjoy the benefits while minimizing the risks. It's a delicate dance, but one that can be worth it in the end.

Don’t Miss: Navigating the Upside Down of Remote Work and Why Companies Fail at It

Is it Possible to Balance Employee Monitoring Pros and Cons? timegram Says Yes!

timegram is a privacy-first time tracking tool that enables organizations to effectively monitor their employees while ensuring everyone benefits from this process. timegram's innovative features are designed to help businesses achieve their goals by providing them with a range of benefits that far outweigh the negative effects of employee monitoring

By using timegram, managers can easily monitor their team's productivity, attendance, and task completion, ensuring that everyone stays on track and meets deadlines. Moreover, the solution provides detailed reports that allow businesses to identify areas where they can improve, ultimately leading to increased efficiency and profitability.

But that's not all. timegram is also highly customizable, allowing organizations to tailor its features to their specific needs. With options to set notifications and customize reports, businesses can stay on top of employee performance without micromanaging their teams. 

The best part? Its privacy-first promise. timegram understands that trust is essential for building a productive team, and that's why it strictly follows a zero-surveillance policy. timegram doesn’t engage in invasive monitoring tactics such as keystroke tracking, screenshots, webcam captures, or microphone monitoring. With this tool, you can trust that your team's privacy is protected while also maintaining effective monitoring of their productivity.

If you're looking for a way to balance the pros and cons of employee monitoring, timegram is the answer. Sign up today and see for yourself how timegram can help you take your business to the next level.

FAQs

What is employee monitoring?

It’s basically when employers keep an eye on what their employees are doing while they're on the clock. This can include things like tracking internet usage, monitoring email and messaging systems, and even using cameras to watch employees in the workplace. It's kind of like having a nosy neighbor who always wants to know what you're up to, except in this case, your boss is the nosy neighbor and they have the power to fire you.

Why is employee monitoring important? 

Employee monitoring can be important for a few reasons. Firstly, it can help ensure that employees are using their time effectively and not spending hours scrolling through cat memes on the internet. Secondly, it can be useful for identifying areas where employees may need additional support or training. And finally, it can help protect a company's sensitive information and assets from being leaked or stolen. So, think of it like having a security guard for your business - they're there to keep things running smoothly and prevent any unwanted surprises.

What are the pros and cons of employee monitoring?

Well, employee monitoring can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, it can increase productivity and efficiency by ensuring that employees are staying on task and not wasting time. On the other hand, it can lead to a lack of trust and autonomy among employees, which can negatively impact morale and job satisfaction. So, it's like having a parent who constantly checks up on you - sometimes it can be helpful, but other times it just feels suffocating.

timegram logo

Ready to use time to your advantage
with timegram?

Give it a shot!

Fatima Mazhar

About the author

Fatimah has over 10 years of experience working with words. When she's not writing, she’s busy setting multiple world records for watching the extended versions of the Lord of the Rings trilogy.

Start Your Journey With Us.

See why remote-friendly organizations globally love using timegram for their teams.

Start Your Journey With Us.

See why remote-friendly organizations globally love using timegram for their teams.

More Interesting Blogs for You

Begin timegraming today to peak team productivity every day

No credit card required
Free forever
Track for FREE

Don’t Leave Empty-Handed!

Do you manage a remote team?

Get this guide to learn how time tracking helps measure remote team performance and why it is crucial to use the right tool for ensuring better employee productivity.

Get Your Guide